Skip to content
X
Two players contest a ruck in an Eltham game

Best & Fairest winners

Development The B Grade honour roll, from 1961 to today.

How the awards changed

Two eras of club awards

1973 – today

Six awards each season

  • Best & Fairest
  • Runner-up
  • Third
  • Coaches Award
  • Most competition votes
  • Leading goal kicker

There was no season in 2020 because of COVID-19.

1948 – 1972

Up to eight awards each season

  • Best & Fairest
  • Runner-up
  • Most Determined
  • Most Consistent
  • Best Teamman
  • Best Utility
  • Most Improved
  • Best Finals Player

Club awards

Two awards go to the best player across a whole part of the club, not just one team.

YearJohn Smith Award (whole men’s club)Brett Sinclair Award (whole women’s club)
2026Jason McCormick
Declan Ayres
Marlo Gardam
2025
Colm Culligan
2024Declan Ayres
2023Jesse Donaldson
2022Jye Lorey

Multiple winners

Most Best & Fairests

  • ×6 Adam Burns 2009–2014
  • ×2 Mikael Avramov 2018, 2019
  • ×2 Darren Arnel 1993, 1994
  • ×2 Ian Smyth 1962, 1963
1973 – today
YearBest & FairestRunner-upThirdCoaches AwardMost Competition VotesLeading Goal Kicker
2026Jye MurphyHarry DownesJames MinahanTom NealeNathan KilbyNathan Kilby
2025Harry DownesDylan ShuteNathan KilbyLiam DoumtsisLiam DoumtsisNathan Kilby
2024Ben SmithJye LoreyKai PorterWilliam MoioBen SmithKai Porter
2023Jozeph Thatcher-BrenerLuke SirrianiLiam WaldronLiam WaldronBenjamin SmithJozeph Thatcher-Brener
2022Sean DesmondJye LoreyRiley ByrneHarry Chandler
Matthew Debney
Jye Lorey League winnerBilly Glasgow
2021Harvey FurlongThomas BurnsJames MinahanLiam Rushton-McCoachJames Snell
James Taglieri
Shannon Waldron
Thomas Burns
2020No season (COVID-19)
2019Mikael AvramovJames SnellLuke Wachinger
Billy Glasgow
Jack PowellTom EvansBilly Glasgow
2018Mikael AvramovJye LoreyKyle O'SullivanVal HilderbrandtMikael AvramovAdam Currie
Sam Warren
2017Luke Ericson
Kieran Keane
Connor O'LearyLachlan MerkelLuke KelsoConnor O'LearyBrendan Ryan
2016Josh LoreyBrendan O'SullivanJamie SmithRyan RomerilJamie SmithHayden Hunt
2015Ailin HouriganKyle O'SullivanLuke McCreeyLachie FindlayTom Snell
Jamie Doukas
Todd Owen
2014Adam BurnsMikael AvramovAilin HouriganHayden HuntJesse FreemanOwen Robinson
2013Adam BurnsLouis EvripidouLachlan MerkelAndrew GrayAdam BurnsAndrew Gray
2012Adam BurnsMikael AvramovMatthew WilliamsonJoshua AndersonAdam BurnsAndrew Gray
2011Adam BurnsRyan BugejaSean WilsonJesse DugganOscar Philp TaylorMatthew Jessop
2010Adam BurnsJames QuinnDavid BrownAdam BurtonAdam BurnsAndrew Gray
2009Adam BurnsKarl McGoughJarrod ShawRyan McAllisterAdam BurnsMick Smith
2008David BrownReid GardamChris WellsAiden SmithDavid BrownMick Smith
2007Reece BuxReid GardamScott McAuliffeMatthew Williamson
2006Matthew TallackNick RichardsonAndrew MoyleBrett AldredBrett AldredMatthew Williamson
2005Andrew MoyleNick RichardsonGrant Pittard
Matthew Tallack
Jack Richardson
2004Danny StricklandAndrew Willoughby
Joel Hewish
Leigh Miller
Chris DawLeigh Miller
2003Dan IrwinScott JacksonLeigh HowseBrett AldredMatthew WeisheitRob Jordon
2002David StreatMichael IddonReid GardamDaniel PriorDavid StreatDavid Streat
2001Paul SmithLuke FernsMatthew WeisheitMatthew WeisheitMatthew Weisheit
Reid Gardam
John Garrard
2000Dean PhilpotsMatthew RogersDavid StreatMichael IddonDavid StreatGreg Wilson
1999Andrew ClarkeGreg WilsonGrant PittardScott JacksonDavid StreatGreg Wilson
1998Andrew TurnerMichael IddonChris DawAndrew TurnerJoe Fisher
Darren Jansen
David Ward
1997Justin GreenJamie CameronMarcus Gardam
Grant Pittard
Justin GreenBret SheaDarren Hartney
1996Gary GriffinGrant PittardRod WhitcherLynton EvansBrett GrantG Baker
1995Michael IddonMatthew RogersGreg WilsonAndrew TurnerGreg Wilson
Steven Kilby
Peter Candy
1994Darren ArnelRohan BurchRod WhitcherGrant PittardBlair PennellAdam Gardam
1993Darren ArnelKevin LynchGreg WilsonBlair Pennell
Grant Pittard
Adam Gardam
1992John GouldingDavid StreatRobert OwenPaul HingstonDarren Campbell
1991Daryl MegnaRay BuhagiarDavid StreatRay BuhagiarRay Buhagiar
Adrian Mezzalira
1990Brett JohnstoneDavid Huxtable
Corey Jewell
  Colin SmythColin Smyth
1989Colin SmythPeter ShawAndy RyanD FlanniganPeter ShawColin Smyth
1988Peter ShawBilly BeruldsenShane LeechPeter ShawJason Schembri
1987Gary FrenchKevin LynchDavid WilsonMark McCarthyAlan RockMark Deany
1986
1985
1984
1983
1982
1981
1980
1979
1978
1977
1976
1975
1974
1973